2 guys :S !!?

ok so the unthinkable happened!! This guy i thought was cute through school then i didnt c for lyk 2 years bumped into me at a friends party and we ended up making out!! But it was one of those things that was just for a bit of fun or so i thought, I went out the next nyt and hooked up with some cute guy that ive known for a while. Know ive found out the guy i knew at school likes me and hes so cute and everything i look for in a guy but hes so quiet its unreal then theres the guy from the night after who isnt shy and ttl cool and cute but not into me as much as the other guy what do i do do i go for one or the other or non at all sum1 help?!?!?!?!